Pets have long been cherished for their companionship and emotional support. However, recent studies are beginning to reveal the extent of the therapeutic benefits that animals, especially dogs, can provide.
In particular, new research on middle-aged women suggests that having a close attachment to a pet may be associated with lower levels of anxiety and depression.
These findings are especially relevant for women with a history of childhood trauma, where a strong bond with a pet seems to play an even more crucial role. This study adds depth to the understanding of how pet companionship can aid mental health, offering insights into the potential healing effects of this unique human-animal bond.
The Healing Bond Between Humans and Dogs: An Overview of the Study
This recent study focused on 214 women who had previously been part of the Nurses’ Health Study 2. Of this group, 140 women were pet owners, with 56% owning a dog and 33% a cat. The study also included a control group of 74 participants who reported never owning a pet. The primary objective was to assess the relationship between pet companionship and reduced symptoms of anxiety and depression, particularly among women with a history of childhood abuse.
Researchers employed a variety of questions to gauge participants’ attachment to their pets. These questions touched on the emotional significance of the pet to the owner, such as whether the pet was considered a friend or family member, whether the owner spoke to or played with the pet, and other behaviors that reflect a deep connection.
The study found that a strong attachment to dogs was notably linked to reduced levels of anxiety and depression.
“The level of attachment to a pet appears to be a crucial factor in how pets help reduce their owners’ risk of depression,” said Eva Schernhammer, MD, DrPH, a Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health adjunct professor and corresponding author of the study.
For women with a history of childhood abuse, this bond was especially impactful, suggesting that the emotional support provided by a pet may fill a void left by previous trauma.
Why Dogs May Be Particularly Effective for Alleviating Depression and Anxiety
The study’s findings align with broader trends observed in pet therapy research, where dogs, in particular, are often seen to offer significant mental health benefits. Owning a dog not only offers companionship but can also encourage physical activity, routine, and even social interaction, all of which contribute positively to mental health.
A meta-analysis of 49 studies previously found that “pet ownership does not seem to influence owners’ mental health,” but it did find that pet owners, especially dog owners, were generally more active. This study suggests that previous research might have missed a key factor: the depth of attachment, rather than mere ownership, which could explain inconsistent results across studies.
“We hypothesize that these inconsistencies may arise because previous studies did not always assess the level of attachment to pets, which might be a more important factor than simply owning a pet,” says Dr. Schernhammer.
By placing greater emphasis on the quality of the human-pet relationship, researchers were able to observe more profound mental health benefits among those with stronger bonds to their pets.
Why Cat Companionship Did Not Show the Same Benefits
Interestingly, the study revealed that while pet attachment overall was linked to lower levels of generalized anxiety, the mental health benefits were significantly less pronounced among women who owned cats. Several potential reasons may account for this discrepancy.
First, the smaller sample size of cat owners in the study may have affected the results.
Alternatively, it could be that cats, being generally more independent than dogs, offer a different type of companionship that may not fulfill the same emotional needs as a dog might.
“Additionally, the social interactions encouraged by dogs — things like walking in the park or meeting other pet owners — may not be as prevalent with cats, who are more likely to stay indoors,” notes Gloria Petruzzelli, PsyD of UC Davis School of Medicine, who was not involved in the study.
The nature of dog ownership often involves more active and socially engaging experiences, which may be particularly beneficial for people with anxiety or depression.
Personal Stories Fueling the Study: Love for Pets Among Researchers
The connection between animals and mental health is not merely an academic pursuit for the researchers involved. Dr. Schernhammer and her team are all pet owners and share a deep love for animals, which partially inspired their research.
“Our research is driven by the growing evidence that pets benefit human health, and a desire to understand whether it’s simply owning a pet or the strength of the bond with the pet that matters more in these benefits,” she explains.
Dr. Schernhammer recalls a touching experience that speaks to the healing potential of pets. Her great-great-aunt, living in a retirement home in Vienna, found new joy when a stray cat “moved in” and quickly became a cherished companion to the residents. This experience highlighted the therapeutic power pets hold to relieve anxiety and loneliness, offering unconditional support and companionship.
Factors to Consider Before Adopting a Pet for Mental Health Benefits
While pet ownership can bring comfort and joy to many, it’s essential to weigh various factors before deciding to bring an animal into one’s life.
Emily Hemendinger, LCSW, MPH, an assistant professor at the University of Colorado Medical Campus, emphasizes that “pet ownership takes responsibility and commitment — financially, physically, and emotionally.” Owning a pet, particularly a dog, requires a significant time investment, and not everyone may find it beneficial for their mental health.
For some people with depression, having a pet to care for can provide purpose and motivation. “For many with depression and feelings of loneliness, a pet can make a huge difference in their life,” Hemendinger explains.
The companionship and responsibility may encourage individuals to get out of bed and engage in daily activities. However, for others, the added responsibility may contribute to feelings of overwhelm, potentially intensifying feelings of depression.
Similarly, people with anxiety may experience mixed effects. Some individuals find that caring for a pet can be calming, while others may feel anxious or guilty if they are unable to meet the pet’s needs.
Hemendinger notes, “Many people don’t know how they will respond to having a pet until they have the pet.” Thus, more research is needed to identify how individual differences in mental health conditions interact with pet ownership.
Moving Forward: The Future of Research on Pet Companionship and Mental Health
The insights from this study contribute to a broader understanding of the relationship between pet ownership and mental health. For researchers like Dr. Schernhammer, these findings suggest that further investigation into the nature of attachment to pets could be valuable.
Future studies may examine more closely the specific attachment styles individuals have with their pets, which could help to clarify why certain people benefit more than others from pet companionship.
Final Thoughts: The Healing Power of Pets and Individualized Support
While pets may not be a universal solution to mental health challenges, this study reinforces the powerful role they can play in the lives of individuals who form deep connections with them. For women, especially those with past trauma, the unconditional support and companionship provided by a dog can help mitigate symptoms of anxiety and depression.
Ultimately, the decision to adopt a pet should be a personal one, influenced by individual needs, lifestyle, and mental health goals. Whether you’re looking to find companionship, encourage routine, or just enjoy the comfort of a loyal friend, pets can offer unique and profound support that benefits mental and emotional well-being.
Recommended For You
