A recent study suggests that aerobic fitness plays a more significant role than diet in reducing the risk of dementia for middle-aged adults.
The Impact of Aerobic Fitness on Dementia Risk
Research indicates that improving aerobic fitness could be more effective in lowering dementia risk than making dietary changes. This study, which included about 9,000 adults averaging 51 years of age with no history of dementia, tracked both physical fitness and eating habits over several years. Participants underwent treadmill tests to measure cardio-respiratory fitness, which refers to the body’s capacity to deliver oxygen to muscles during exercise. The test results were expressed in metabolic equivalents (METs), reflecting how much oxygen is consumed during physical exertion.
Aerobic Fitness Trumps Diet in Reducing Dementia Risk
Over the course of about nine years, 1,500 participants developed dementia. Interestingly, following the heart- and brain-healthy Mediterranean and DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension) diets did not appear to influence dementia risk significantly. “This study confirms the results of prior studies that suggest nothing is more important to reduce one’s risk of dementia than aerobic exercise,” says Dr. Andrew Budson, professor and associate director of the Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center at Boston University, who was not involved in the new study.
However, for each 1-MET increase in exercise capacity, the risk of developing dementia was reduced by 5 to 6 percent. This finding highlights the potential power of aerobic exercise in maintaining brain health as individuals age.
Limitations of the Study: Short-Term Data and Self-Reported Diets
Despite its valuable findings, the study has limitations. Researchers only assessed participants’ eating habits over a three-day period, which may not fully reflect long-term dietary patterns. Additionally, participants self-reported their food intake, which could lead to inaccuracies in the data. In contrast, the researchers used objective measures to assess exercise capacity, providing a more accurate representation of physical fitness.
Furthermore, the study did not establish direct causality between diet or exercise and dementia, meaning it cannot definitively prove that either factor directly influences brain health. Other unmeasured changes in participants’ lifestyles over the course of the study could also have affected the results.
Exercise, Not Just Diet, Key to Brain Health
While the study does not dismiss the importance of a healthy diet, its findings align with growing evidence that physical activity is crucial for preserving cognitive function. According to Dr. Mika Kivimaki, professor and chair of social epidemiology at University College London, “The biggest drop in dementia risk happens when people move from being completely sedentary to engaging in some form of physical activity.” Studies tracking physical activity from midlife into old age consistently show the benefits of staying active. Dr. Kivimaki also emphasizes that “Being active at any age seems to have a positive impact on cognitive health, so it’s never too late to start.”
The Role of Diet in Brain Health
While exercise seems to have the upper hand in dementia prevention, the American Heart Association (AHA) still advocates for the Mediterranean and DASH diets as part of a holistic approach to brain health. Both diets emphasize the importance of fresh fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean sources of protein, such as fish and poultry.
Prioritizing Fitness for Cognitive Longevity
In summary, the evidence suggests that while diet plays an important role in brain health, maintaining good aerobic fitness may be even more crucial for reducing dementia risk as we age. Incorporating regular physical activity into one’s routine may be the most effective strategy for promoting cognitive longevity.
The study underscores the importance of exercise, showing that even small improvements in physical activity can make a significant difference in brain health over time.
Recommended For You
