A recent Consumer Reports investigation has raised concerns over elevated lead levels in various cinnamon products, identifying 12 brands with potentially harmful concentrations. Testing extended to several brands of cinnamon and five-spice powders, with findings showing that even a small amount—just a quarter teaspoon—of the most contaminated products may pose health risks.
Key Highlights:
- High Lead Content Detected: Consumer Reports revealed that multiple brands of cinnamon and five-spice powders contain dangerously high lead levels, making them a potential health hazard.
- Health Risks of Lead Exposure: Lead is a toxic substance that can affect both children and adults. Prolonged or high-level exposure may result in high blood pressure, damage to the kidneys and brain, and reproductive issues, including infertility and impotence.
- Discarding Unsafe Products: Experts recommend disposing of cinnamon products that exceed safe lead levels to minimize potential health risks.
Consumer Reports recently sounded the alarm on high lead content in some ground cinnamon products, underscoring health risks associated with regular use of certain brands. This investigation examined 36 products, including pure ground cinnamon and spice blends such as garam masala and five-spice powder. Alarmingly, one-third of these products had such elevated lead levels that experts advised against using them entirely.
Cinnamon Products Under Scrutiny
According to Dr. James Rogers, Consumer Reports’ director of food safety research and testing, even a minimal amount of these high-lead products—around one-quarter teaspoon—contains more lead than is safe for consumption in a single day. “Even small amounts pose a risk because lead can accumulate in the body, and there can be multiple sources in your diet, so it adds up,” Dr. Rogers explained. His warning underscores the risks of cumulative exposure, which can have serious long-term health effects.
The Consumer Reports findings align with several U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) warnings issued over recent months about specific cinnamon products with unsafe lead levels. Last fall, over 500 individuals, many of them children, reported illnesses after consuming cinnamon-flavored applesauce pouches that contained extremely high lead levels, prompting a major recall of these products.
The Health Risks of Lead
Lead is a heavy metal that infiltrates various bodily tissues, including the brain, kidneys, and liver, where it accumulates over time. Once lead enters the body, it can spread to bones, teeth, and hair, often persisting as lead phosphate deposits. Lead exposure produces free radicals, which trigger oxidative stress and damage cells. Long-term exposure to even small amounts of lead can result in significant health issues, including high blood pressure, kidney damage, brain impairment, infertility, and impotence.
“Children and pregnant women should particularly limit lead exposure, given the long-term irreversible cognitive deficits caused,” explains Jenna Forsyth, PhD, a research scientist at Stanford University’s King Center for Global Development, who works to reduce lead exposure in developing regions. However, she emphasizes that lead poses a danger to anyone, as high exposure can lead to various adverse health effects, including IQ reduction, kidney failure, and cardiovascular disease. Chronic exposure increases lead accumulation in the body, making it increasingly difficult for the body to eliminate this toxic metal over time.
Disposing of Unsafe Products
Consumer Reports identified 12 cinnamon products and spice blends with lead levels exceeding one part per million, the threshold used by New York state as a recall benchmark. To mitigate risks, Consumer Reports advises consumers to carefully inspect their pantry and dispose of any products from the following brands, which have been flagged for high lead content:
– Paras Cinnamon Powder
– EGN Cinnamon Powder
– Mimi’s Products Ground Cinnamon
– Bowl & Basket Ground Cinnamon
– Rani Brand Ground Cinnamon
– Zara Foods Cinnamon Powder
– Three Rivers Cinnamon Stick Powder
– Yu Yee Brand Five Spice Powder
– BaiLiFeng Five Spice Powder
– Spicy King Five Spices Powder
– Badia Cinnamon Powder
– Deep Cinnamon Powder
Consumer Reports also tested brands with lower lead levels, identifying some products as “okay to use” and others as “best to use” due to very low lead content. The six brands in the “best” category included:
– Sadaf Seven Spice
– 365 Whole Foods Market Ground Cinnamon
– Loisa Organic Cinnamon
– Morton & Bassett San Francisco 100% Ground Cinnamon
– Sadaf Cinnamon Powder
– 365 Whole Foods Market Organic Ground Cinnamon
Dr. Rogers noted that many products with elevated lead content were found in smaller markets and international food stores, advising consumers to “stick with mainstream brands” to reduce potential exposure.
Sources of Lead Contamination in Cinnamon
How does lead end up in cinnamon? According to Consumer Reports, some lead contamination is due to natural absorption from the soil in which cinnamon trees grow, while other contamination may result from industrial processes. Dr. Rogers elaborated, saying, “Cinnamon trees grow for 10 years before harvest, giving lots of time to accumulate lead in the bark.” Contaminated equipment, storage, and packaging may also introduce lead to the products before they reach consumers.
Dr. Forsyth further explains that understanding the health impact of lead exposure is complex. “It depends on the medium lead is stored in, the lead levels, the characteristics of the lead [such as particle size], and the nutritional status of the person,” she says. For instance, people who are deficient in iron or calcium may absorb more lead, amplifying the risk. Some research suggests that vitamins and minerals like vitamin C, calcium, iron, selenium, and zinc might help decrease lead absorption by the body.
Lead Beyond Cinnamon
Cinnamon is not the only product raising concerns about lead contamination. Recent reports have detected harmful levels of lead in other consumables, including chocolate chips, brownie mixes, and turmeric. This prevalence of lead in various food items highlights the need for vigilance and informed choices.
Dr. Rogers advises consumers not to panic but to remain informed. “Don’t panic, but become an informed consumer,” he says. Following reliable safety advisories and opting for well-tested brands can reduce lead exposure and its associated health risks.
As research on lead contamination in food products continues, consumers have a critical role in making choices that protect their health and that of their families. Staying informed about product recalls, selecting products from reputable brands, and understanding the risks of cumulative lead exposure are essential steps toward safer, healthier dietary habits.
Recommended For You
